Seneca’s Elston: Why I adore Gina Miller

Added 4th September 2017

Gina Miller is a figure to be admired according to Seneca Investment Management’s CEO Peter Elston, who has added his voice to criticism of weak active managers.

Seneca’s Elston: Why I adore Gina Miller

In a strongly-worded investment note, Elston said he abhorred poor active management and pointed the finger at large investment firms who “peddle the notion that bigger is better”.

It has both unfairly penalised savers focusing on retirement and given the entire industry a bad name, Elston said, adding he admired Gina Miller, a long-time critic of active management and vocal opponent of Brexit.

“While I abhor poor active management, I adore Gina Miller (on a strictly professional basis I should add),” Elston said.

“I too get an itch when I think ‘people are being bullies, or being dishonest or hypocritical’. Most big fund management companies for me tick all three of those boxes.”

He added: “There’s plenty of evidence that most actively managed funds fail to beat their benchmark net of costs.

"The implication of this – and the associated headlines – is that funds that beat their benchmark have done a good job, and that funds whose performance is in line with the benchmark have achieved what they set out to achieve. This has to be wrong.”

To rid the industry of the stigma of poor active managers, Elston said funds should aim to beat benchmarks by far wider margins than many do currently.

They could start by sticking their necks out and stating by what percentage they will beat the respective benchmark measurements, such as FTSE All Share +3%.

It is something already in action at Seneca, he added.

Elston added: “I’d argue that the objectives of most actively managed funds are not ambitious enough. Perhaps this is why the active management industry is so despised. Many, including me, think it is still providing a safe harbour for the cowardly.”

Visitor's Comments Add your comment

Add Your Comment

We won't publish your address

About Author

Louise Hill

Senior Reporter

Louise joined Portfolio Adviser in December 2016 as one of the editorial team’s news reporters based in London. Originally from Liverpool, she is an NCTJ-qualified journalist and began her career in 2014 working on local newspapers.



Investment Strategy




PA Channel Islands November 2017
PA Channel Islands November 2017

Tuesday 14 November
Royal Yacht Hotel, Jersey

PA Alternative Ucits November 2017
PA Alternative Ucits November 2017

Tuesday 7 November 
Furniture Makers' Hall

PA Global 2017
PA Global 2017

Thursday 23 November
M by Montcalm Shoreditch Tech City

PA Emerging Markets November 2017
PA Emerging Markets November 2017

Tuesday 28 November
Radisson Blu Edwardian Bloomsbury Street Hotel