Brooks Macdonald: Now is a dangerous time to invest in passives

Added 10th May 2017

The hype around passive products has never been more intense, but Brooks Macdonald Asset Management's Jon Gumpel warns that there could be danger ahead for passive investors.

Brooks Macdonald: Now is a dangerous time to invest in passives

There has been a tremendous amount of fanfare around the passives industry, as many active managers struggle to justify fees against lacklustre performance.

Because of this, active managers and wealth managers have felt additional pressure to hop on board the passives train and expand their product offering.

Portfolio Adviser surveyed a group of global asset managers with substantial UK operations back in April and found that 69% of respondents felt the perceived threat from passives would push them to develop their own trackers.

Before a CISI debate on active versus passive investing, a group of wealth managers were asked which management style they were currently favouring. 

Though a slight majority came out in favour of passives ahead of the presentations, 75% were in favour of active management following the debate.

In the active versus passive debate, Gumpel is pretty firmly on the side of the active managers.

But, the Brooks Macdonald co-founder and manager of the Defensive Capital Fund thinks there is a very practical, non-partisan reason to be wary of passive products.

Market dispersion is on the rise, he said, which should provide a major headwind for trackers and a beneficial tailwind for active managers.

“Passive funds benefit from low dispersion. And following the US election, the S&P 500’s 3-month return dispersion has rebounded after an extended period of being quite low.  

“To my mind, there’s a real danger in being in passive strategies at the moment with the scope for a dispersion to increase dramatically. That will be a time that active managers should be able to outperform.”

Kames Income Hub


Vincent McEntegart, manager of the Kames Diversified Monthly Income Fund, explains how he aims to deliver a stable and sustainable income of 5% p.a.*, paid monthly, by investing in a range of asset classes

Square Mile Research

Premier Multi Asset Global Growth - Alex Farlow
Premier Multi Asset Global...

Talking Factsheets is a video service for users...

Visitor's Comments Add your comment

Add Your Comment

We won't publish your address

About Author

Kristen McGachey

Senior Reporter

Kristen joined Last Word Media and the world of financial journalism in April 2016, leaving behind a career in a legal publishing firm as a senior researcher turned assistant editor.

This native Angelino initially moved to the UK in 2008 to complete her undergraduate studies at the University of Nottingham. She subsequently obtained a Masters degree in Philosophy with Literature from the University of Warwick.



Investment Strategy




PA Dublin October 2017
PA Dublin October 2017

Tuesday 10 October
Westbury Hotel, Dublin

PA US 2017
PA US 2017

Tuesday 17 October
Furniture Makers' Hall

PA Channel Islands November 2017
PA Channel Islands November 2017

Tuesday 14 November
Royal Yacht Hotel, Jersey

PA Alternative Ucits November 2017
PA Alternative Ucits November 2017

Tuesday 7 November 
Furniture Makers' Hall

Sponsored Content