PA ANALYSIS: Green investing has an image problem

Added 10th October 2017

If anything, the flurry of studies during this year's Good Money Week have proved that green investing has to overcome a number of hurdles before it really takes off.

PA ANALYSIS: Green investing has an image problem

Although ethical investing as a concept is gaining in popularity, it still only accounts for a small sliver, or 1.2%, of the total funds under management in the industry, according to the latest figures from the Investment Association (IA).

By contrast, retail investors have pumped more than £23bn into UK authorised funds year-to-date alone, surpassing the annual net retail sales in both 2015 and 2016.

It doesn’t help that many out of the box, ambitious ethical projects have failed to get off the ground or gain much traction.

Just today, Daniel Godfrey announced his post-IA venture, The People’s Trust, had been unable to garner enough support from certain investor groups.

The cruellest irony of all is that his sustainably-motivated passion project came to an end during Good Money Week.

No place like home

When the Wisdom Council asked a group of investors about which aspects of their lives they act the most socially responsible in, respondents were far more likely to say they had a green approach to the running of their household (57%) and child-rearing (42%) than the way they invest (22%).   

Juliet Schooling Latter, director of FundCalibre, agrees that there is a clear disconnect between the shifting public narrative about socially responsible and environmentally-friendly living and the way people think about their investment strategies.

“Trump's tearing up of the climate change agreement and Sports Direct's poor treatment of employees have both made the headlines in recent months – underlining the fact that environmental and social issues are very much front of mind.

“However, when it comes to our investments, we are a little less vocal.”

Dispelling the myth

One of the biggest misperceptions about the sector, which could be watering down demand, is the fear that ethical funds will struggle to outperform their non-ethical counterparts.

But this fear doesn’t line up with the most recent performance stats, even over longer time horizons of three to five years.

Data from Lipper Investment Management and Moneyfacts confirms that in general ethical funds have had a competitive edge over non-ethical funds, returning 16.81% over the last 12 months compared with the latter’s 15.2%.

These figures should reassure investors that “you don't need to sacrifice returns for your principles,” says Schooling Latter, who lists EdentreeAmityUK, the Rathbone Ethical Bond fund and Standard Life Investments UK Ethical fund as three standouts deserving of a higher profile.

Seven Investment Management senior manager Camilla Ritchie also disagrees that sustainable investing will end up being a drag on returns.

“Sustainable investing can actually improve returns and reduce risk, potentially protecting your portfolio from some nasty shocks,” she points out.

“For instance in May 2015, Volkswagen fell out of the MSCI ACWI ESG Index – an index which screens for environmental, social and governance factors – over governance concerns. Months later, diesel emission test results were exposed as being rigged and the share price plunged.”

While Ritchie acknowledges “this is an extreme example,” she argues that by paying attention to a company's environmental, social or governance contributions, future pitfalls and financial pain can be avoided.

Visitor's Comments Add your comment

Add Your Comment

We won't publish your address

About Author

Kristen McGachey

Senior Reporter

Kristen joined Last Word Media and the world of financial journalism in April 2016, leaving behind a career in a legal publishing firm as a senior researcher turned assistant editor.

This native Angelino initially moved to the UK in 2008 to complete her undergraduate studies at the University of Nottingham. She subsequently obtained a Masters degree in Philosophy with Literature from the University of Warwick.



Investment Strategy




PA Channel Islands November 2017
PA Channel Islands November 2017

Tuesday 14 November
Royal Yacht Hotel, Jersey

PA Alternative Ucits November 2017
PA Alternative Ucits November 2017

Tuesday 7 November 
Furniture Makers' Hall

PA Global 2017
PA Global 2017

Thursday 23 November
M by Montcalm Shoreditch Tech City

PA Emerging Markets November 2017
PA Emerging Markets November 2017

Tuesday 28 November
Radisson Blu Edwardian Bloomsbury Street Hotel